Contact Us

Cruise Ship Law Blog


Royal Caribbean Cruise Passengers Killed During Shore Excursion In Mexico

November 21, 2012

When an accident onboard a cruise line takes place, victims and their loved ones can seek legal counsel with a cruise ship injury attorney to determine if they qualify for any compensation, including money damages and medical care. Most times, accidents onboard cruise vessels are the result of negligence, inexperience or someone’s wrongdoing. If a cruise operator is found to have contributed to the incident, they may be held liable for their actions.

However, claims against cruise lines may also be brought if the injury or fatality occurred while during a shore excursion. A recent fatal accident during a shore excursion in Mexico is just one of the many examples of accidents that can take place ashore. A couple vacationing with friends on Royal Caribbean’s Liberty of the Seas was killed during a third-party shore excursion in Cozumel, Mexico when their sand buggy hit a guardrail and crashed.

Forty-one year old Jim Melillo and his 39-year old girlfriend, Susan Borges, were with a group of roughly 28 friends participating in the excursion. A friend was driving their sand buggy at the time of the accident. The driver and his wife sustained injuries, but were not seriously hurt.

Royal Caribbean officials extended their condolences to the victims’ loved ones in a statement sent to Cruise Critic, which read: “The guests, who were sailing on Liberty of the Seas, died while ashore in Cozumel, Mexico. The guests had been participating in a sand buggy shore excursion that was not sponsored by the company.”

The group of friends had contracted with a third-party in Cancun to rent the sand buggies for a six-hour tour that included lunch and swimming on a private beach. According to the Orlando Sentinel article, members of the group said several of the buggies seemed “ill-kept” and did not have seat belts. However, Mexican authorities investigated the incident and found no fault with the shore excursion company.

Melillo and Borges were part of a large group of roughly 40 friends on Liberty of the Seas’ four-night sailing from Port Everglades, Florida, which departed November 15 and returned on November 19.

While this shore excursion was not directly sponsored by Royal Caribbean, there are many times in which third-party accidents can be traced back to the negligence of the cruise line. There are also times in which the shore excursion operators themselves can be held liable as well, despite preliminary police investigations. After any accident occurs at sea or in port, victims have a right to turn to a cruise injury attorney to protect their rights and see if they are entitled to receive damages.

At Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman, P.A., our attorneys are dedicated to representing those who have been hurt or killed in a cruise-related accident. With over 80 years of combined experience in the field of maritime law. Call us today to discuss your options and determine if you qualify for compensation.

PHOTO CREDIT: Cruise Critic

Back to Cruise Ship Law Blog

Our Testimonials

  • Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman

    I would like to thank all of the staff at LMAW, P.A., especially Jason Marguilies and his paralegal Maggie, for their support and hard work during my lawsuit. They were extremely helpful throughout the whole experience.

    - Annette Guzman

    Rating: 5/5 More

Unsafe on the High Seas by Charles Lipcon

Unsafe on the High Seas by Charles Lipcon

The Ultimate Guide to keep you & your family safe while taking a cruise. Just released as eBook for
Kindle or iTunes - just 99c to download!

Unsafe on the High Seas on Kindle Unsafe on the High Seas on Nook Unsafe on the High Seas on iTunes
Cruise Ship Lawyer App

Problem on a cruise?
There's an app for that.

Thousands of passengers are injured on cruise ships every year. Are you prepared? Download our free app.

Cruise Ship Lawyer App for Apple Store Cruise Ship Lawyer App for Google Store

Cruise Line Law Reporter

Sign up to receive future issues of the Cruise Line Law Reporter.

Steps to Take if You are injured on a Ship

Injured while on a cruise ship? Learn what you should and shouldn’t do.

What Every Cruise Ship Passenger Needs to know

Although you are preparing for a vacation, you should be aware of cruising dangers.