|
|
Cruise Lines Responsible for Medical Malpractice to Passengers | Press Release |
August 28, 2003
Read the Opinion [PDF, 70Kb]
The law firm of Lipcon, Margulies & Alsina, P.A. has been successful in obtaining a landmark decision from the Third District Court of Appeals of Florida which now makes cruise lines directly liable for the negligent actions of medical staff and doctors aboard its ships who render bad medical care to passengers aboard its ships. In reaching its decision, the Florida appeals court expressly rejected an earlier decision of the Federal Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, styled Barbetta v. S/S Bermuda Star, which held that a cruise ship was not liable for the negligence of duly qualified doctors that it selects to render medical care to passengers aboard its ships. The Barbetta decision was relied upon by cruise lines to completely insulate themselves from claims by injured passengers who received bad medical care aboard ships.
This new decision stems from the claim of Elizabeth Carlisle, a young Michigan girl who was traveling aboard a Carnival Cruise Lines ship with her family when she fell ill with abdominal pain, lower back pain, and gastrointestinal difficulties. When she presented to the ship's physician, Dr. Mauro Neri - a physician who has no professional or residential address in the United States, the Carlisle family was repeatedly advised that Elizabeth was suffering from the flu. When Elizabeth's symptoms did not subside, the family decided to discontinue their cruise in Mexico and fly home to Michigan where Elizabeth was diagnosed as having a ruptured appendix. As a result of the rupture and subsequent infection, Elizabeth suffered debilitating complications including painful bowel adhesions and possible sterility. However, when her parents filed suit against Carnival in Miami-Dade County, Florida court, the Judge, Jon Gordon, decided not to allow the case to progress to trial, instead granting summary judgment against the Carlisles based upon the Barbetta decision. The Carlisle's attorneys, who have represented hundreds of injured cruise passengers, appealed the judge's decision. The Carlisle decision rendered by the Florida appeals court reversed the summary judgment granted by the lower court judge and will allow the Carlisles to proceed with their lawsuit against Carnival.
The Carlisle decision is based upon the reality that cruise passengers at sea and in medical distress do not have any meaningful choice but to seek treatment from the ship's doctor or nurse. This is a reality which was rejected by the Federal appeals court which decided Barbetta. The Barbetta decision was based on the fallacy that a cruise passenger in need of medical attention has some choice or option over the medical care available to them while the ship is at sea. The truth is, however, that there are no options for a cruise passenger who is in need of medical attention and the ship is hundreds or thousands of miles from its next port. If there was no doctor aboard the ship, the ship's captain would have to divert the ship to the nearest port so that a passenger in need of emergency medical care could receive it; however, if the captain diverts the ship, it will interfere with the cruise line's carefully scheduled itinerary. Nevertheless, if the captain fails to divert the ship in a medical emergency, the cruise line would be held responsible for the captain's decision and its impact on the ill or injured passenger. The Barbetta decision had allowed the cruise lines to render themselves effectively immune from ever having to make such decisions by allowing them to hire non-U.S. licensed doctors, classify them as "independent contractors" and then not worry about the medical care rendered to its passengers. Fortunately, the Carlisle decision ends all of that and puts the responsibility for passenger care where it belongs - on the cruise line.
Read the Opinion [PDF, 70Kb]
|
|
The Attorney Who Never Loses | Selecta Magazine |
|
| $965 injury claim leads to $3.5 million jury award |
South Florida Sun-Sentinel |
|
| $6.1 million awarded in case of seaman killed on cruise ship |
The Sun-Sentinel |
|
|
Accidents aboard ships do happen, but not very often | Miami Herald |
|
|
Colin Farrell's personal dresser from Miami Vice suing production company | A Current Affair |
|
|
Cruise lines adding cell service | A Current Affair |
|
|
Cruise workers' health a concern | Florida Today |
|
|
A Current Affair special 1: Missing cruise passenger George Smith | A Current Affair |
|
|
A Current Affair special 2: Cruise Ship Rape & Sexual Assaults | A Current Affair |
|
|
A Current Affair special 3: Crime on the High Seas | A Current Affair |
|
|
A Current Affair special 4: Crime on Cruise Ships | A Current Affair |
|
|
|
Blinded in attack from Iran, seaman awarded $1 million | The Miami Herald |
|
|
Carnival Cruise employee arrested on sex charge | St. Petersburg Times |
|
|
Carnival Cruises Sued by Family of Wisconsin Woman Who Disappeared | USA TODAY |
|
|
Carroll jury awards $2.5 million | Canton Ohio Newspaper |
|
|
Cause of Ship's Blast Still Unclear | The Miami Herald |
|
| Chaplain's Corner |
The Seafarer |
|
| Charles Lipcon interviewed on Sky Radio for American Airlines. |
 |
|
| Charles Lipcon on George Smith Case |
Scarborough Country |
|
| Charles Lipcon on George Smith Case |
Scarborough Country |
|
| Charles Lipcon interviewed live on MSNBC regarding Congressional investigation of George Smith case |
Scarborough Country |
|
| Charles Lipcon on George Smith Case |
Heartland With John Kasich |
|
| Charles Lipcon on George Smith Case |
Big Story Weekend Edition |
|
| Charles Lipcon on George Smith Case |
MSNBC News Live |
|
| Crewmen Work in Fear of Being Fired, Deported |
Sun-Sentinel |
|
| Crime Rocks The Boats |
TIME Magazine |
|
| Cruise execs: Crime concerns overblown |
Florida Today |
|
|
Cruise Line Crime | Court TV |
|
| Cruise line faces revived lawsuit |
Orlando Sentinel |
|
| Cruise liners no luxury for crew as long hours, low wages prevail |
The Sun-Sentinel |
|
|
Cruise lines liable for MDs - Court rules against Carnival | The Miami Herald |
|
|
CRUISE LINES: Missing cruise cases spur calls for scrutiny | The Miami Herald |
|
| Cruise lines operate under layers of laws - Vessels fly different flags; rules complex across seas |
The Miami Herald |
|
|
Cruise Lines Responsible for Medical Malpractice to Passengers | Press Release |
|
|
Cruiseline Sexual Assaults on FOX News | FOX 11 News |
|
|
CRUISE SAFETY: If you use your head, you couldn't be any place safer | The Miami Herald |
|
|
Cruise workers must endure long hours for others' leisure | Houston Chronicle |
|
|
Cruise Passenger Says Ship Employee Raped Her | South Florida Sun-Sentinel |
|
|
Cruises...Hot Vacations...Cold Truth / Cruise Ship Crimes | FOX26 NEWS |
|
|
Fee Lawsuits Filed Against Cruise Lines | Herald.com |
|
|
Fortune Awaits Sailor Being Held in Cuban Jail | The Miami Herald |
|
| For Charles Lipcon, business has never been better |
Miami Herald |
|
|
Health Care Often Misses the Boat | The Miami Herald |
|
|
Hope's Story | A Current Affair |
|
|
Hope's Story | A Current Affair |
|
| How to take steps to make your cruise safer |
The Sun-Sentinel |
|
| Injured seaman wins $25.8 million award |
The Miami Herald |
|
|
Jamie's Story: A Cruise Rape Victim speaks out | A Current Affair |
|
Jane's Story | A Current Affair |
|
|
Jason Margulies And The George Smith Case | MSNBC News Live |
|
|
Jury relives last minutes of doomed JAL 747 flight | The Seattle Times |
|
| Kin of woman missing on cruise sue Carnival |
Miami Herald |
|
| Lawsuits filed over 'First Strikes' |
Numismatic News |
|
| Lawyers turn cruise lawsuits into industry |
Miami Herald |
|
|
Lipcon on Geraldo show covering Cruise Passenger Disappearances | Geraldo at Large |
|
|
Lipcon receives award | N. American Maritime Ministry Conference |
|
|
Lipcon.com Receives National Recognition | Law Office Computing |
|
|
Man Disappears From Cruiseship | The O'Reilly Factor |
|
|
Medical Woes Sink Cruise Careers | FloridaToday.com |
|
| Michael Winkleman, Recent Law School Graduate |
|
|
| Missing woman's husband finds hope in lawsuit |
GM Today |
|
| Mizener continues in midst of cruise fight |
Waukesha Freeman (Conley) |
|
| Newfoundland Air Crash |
ATLA Law Reporter |
|
| Norwegian suits to Philippines? Cruise line likely to seek transfer |
The Miami-Herald |
|
| NTSB to investigate cause of Norway blast |
The Miami Herald |
|
|
Parasailing accident investigated |
Bradenton Herald / East Manatee Herald |
|
|
Passenger deaths a cruise concern |
FloridaToday.com |
|
| Rotary Sending Used Pacemakers to Guatemala |
The Miami Herald |
|
| Seaman's family awarded $6 million |
The Miami Herald |
|
| Ship steward's tip income can be included in maintenance and cure |
ATLA Law Reporter |
|
| Some Question Health Care on Cruise Ships |
Associated Press |
|
| SOVEREIGN ISLANDS -- A special report.; Getting Sick on the High Seas: A Question of Accountability
|
The New York Times |
|
| Tensions rise between "Norway" widows, cruise line over lawsuits |
South Florida Sun-Sentinel |
|
| The $25.8 million dollar man - A case without precedent |
Voces/ Miami Mensual |
|
| Video shows passenger going overboard |
Florida Today |
|
| Widow wins suit with cruise line |
The Sun-Sentinel |
|
| Workers alarmed cruisers |
Florida Today |
